The Best Cutting Mat for Quilting: Size, Type, and My Top Recommendation

If you’re new to quilting, you’ll quickly learn that your cutting mat, rotary cutter, and quilting ruler are the three tools you’ll reach for the most.

But here’s the thing: there are so many different cutting mats out there that choosing one can feel ultra confusing.

So, let me save you the guesswork. Here’s exactly what I recommend when you’re buying a cutting mat for quilting – and a brand that I personally love.

What Size Cutting Mat Do You Need?

For most quilters, an A2 size cutting mat is ideal.

Size: 23 x 17 inches (600 x 430 mm)

Why: When quilting fabric comes off the bolt, it’s folded in half and usually measures about 22-23 inches across. This size mat will fit that folded width perfectly, so you can cut strips and pieces without wrestling fabric off the edge.

If you do a lot of cutting (like I do for my shop!), you might eventually want a larger A1 mat, but A2 is a brilliant starting size.

Matte vs. Shiny: Why Surface Matters

Here’s where things get interesting: not all cutting mats are created equal.

Shiny mats look pretty in the shop, but they’re slippery. When your ruler slips, your rotary cutter slips, and that’s when accidents happen. Yes, that can mean cut fingers (ouch!) but it can also – and more likely - mean that you get inaccurate measuring and cutting, which is not what we want.

Matte mats have a slightly textured/rougher surface. That little bit of grip means your fabric and ruler stay put while you cut. Safer and more accurate.

💡 Tip: When in doubt, give the mat a feel in-store. If it’s smooth like glass, pop it back. If it’s a bit rough, that’s the one you want.

My Favourite Cutting Mat Brand

There are some excellent brands out there (Creative Grids and Fiskars are good options), but the brand I always come back to is Olfa.

Yes, Olfa mats cost a bit more, but they last for years, and I’d much rather spend a few more pounds buying one good mat than replace a cheaper one later. However, if you’re on a budget, there are some good brands around which still have that rough surface you’re after. It’s worth having a look in the big sewing and quilting shows and exhibitions, because you’re likely to get a high quality cutting mat at a discounted show price.

By the way, choose a good thickness. A sturdy mat will last longer and protect your table better.

Invest in a mat you love – it’s worth it for both safety and enjoyment (it’s not a fun experience trying to cut fabric that’s sliding around).

You Might Also Like To Read:

Why You Shouldn’t Use a Cutting Mat for Measuring

Cutting Mat Care and Maintenance

Happy (and safe!) cutting,

Kim x